Skip to main content

Foreign Pensions and U.S. Tax: PFICs, FBAR, Form 8938, and Forms 3520/3520-A

Why a foreign pension's local tax deferral doesn't carry over to the U.S., how to classify a pension before anything else, why Canada's RRSP is an exception and Australian superannuation remains unresolved, UK Article 18(1) vs 18(5) treaty deferral, the Rev. Proc. 2020-17 exemption from Forms 3520/3520-A, and a full worked example of the §1291 excess distribution cost on a UK auto-enrolment pension.

November 11, 2026 · 26 min readBy TaxLatitude Editorial TeamUpdated November 2026Drafted from primary sources, cited and dated · our method
On this page · 11 sections

A pension that is tax-deferred in the country where you earned it is not automatically tax-deferred in the United States. The U.S. tax code gives special treatment to U.S. plans, such as 401(k)s, IRAs, and plans qualified under IRC §401(a). A foreign plan gets the same kind of protection only when a specific treaty provision, or a specific piece of IRS guidance, grants it. Many Americans abroad assume their workplace pension is "the local 401(k)" as far as the IRS is concerned. That is true for some countries and some plan types. It is not a general rule.

The gap matters most for defined contribution pensions invested in pooled funds. The default fund in a UK auto-enrolment pension or an Australian super account is, in most cases, exactly the kind of foreign investment fund that the passive foreign investment company (PFIC) rules were written to catch. A foreign pension can also count as a foreign trust, a foreign financial account for the FBAR, and a specified foreign financial asset on Form 8938, all at the same time and under different rules.

This guide covers foreign pensions held by U.S. persons. It does not repeat three of our other guides:

  • Our guide to U.S. retirement accounts for Americans living abroad covers the opposite situation: a U.S. 401(k) or IRA owned by someone who lives outside the United States.
  • Our general PFIC guide covers foreign mutual funds and ETFs held directly in a brokerage account. Here we apply the same rules only where a pension wrapper changes the analysis.
  • Our Form 3520-A guide explains how to file for a foreign trust in general. Here we only ask whether your pension falls into that category. If it does, and no exemption applies, use that guide for the filing details.

Key takeaways

  • Local tax deferral does not carry over to the U.S. by default. Tax relief that your country gives on contributions or investment growth has no U.S. effect unless a treaty article or IRS procedure gives your specific type of plan deferral for U.S. purposes.
  • Classify the pension first. A state pension with no individual account is a very different U.S. problem from a defined contribution pot invested in funds. Nearly all of the PFIC risk sits in the second category.
  • Canada's RRSP and RRIF are the exception, not the model. They get automatic U.S. deferral through Article XVIII(7) of the U.S.-Canada treaty and Rev. Proc. 2014-55. That relief is tied to Canadian plans and does not apply to plans in other countries.
  • Australian superannuation is still unresolved. As of November 2026, the IRS has issued no published guidance on superannuation. The U.S.-Australia treaty does not mention it and has no provision deferring tax on growth inside a pension fund. Any position you take is a position, not a settled answer.
  • UK pensions depend on where you live and on the treaty article you rely on. A U.S. resident with a UK pension has clear treaty deferral under Article 18(1). A U.S. citizen living in the UK has to rely on the narrower Article 18(5), which covers employment-based schemes only and is subject to caps.
  • FBAR, Form 8938, and Forms 3520/3520-A are three separate obligations. Each has its own definition, threshold, and exceptions. An exemption from one, such as Rev. Proc. 2020-17 for Form 3520, does not exempt you from the others.

Step 1: Classify your pension before anything else

Every later question depends on what kind of arrangement you have. Whether the PFIC rules apply, whether the plan is a foreign trust, and how to report its value all turn on this. Use the four categories below as a starting point.

Category Typical examples Individual account / identifiable assets? PFIC exposure FBAR / Form 8938 starting point
A. State / social security pension UK State Pension, Canada Pension Plan, Australian Age Pension, French régime général No None in practice. There are no fund units that could be attributed to you. Not a financial account for FBAR purposes. Excluded from Form 8938 as foreign social security.
B. Defined benefit occupational pension Final-salary or career-average employer schemes No. You hold a promise of future benefits, not a share of specific assets. Generally not analyzed as an indirect PFIC holding, because you have no proportionate interest in particular fund units. Reportable on Form 8938 as a foreign pension interest, with special valuation rules. FBAR treatment of a pure DB entitlement is less clear-cut.
C. Defined contribution workplace pension UK auto-enrolment schemes (master trusts, group personal pensions), Australian industry and retail super funds, Hong Kong MPF, Irish PRSAs Yes. You have an account invested in one or more pooled funds, often a default fund. High. The underlying funds are usually PFICs. Generally reportable on both.
D. Self-directed personal pension UK SIPP, Australian self-managed super fund (SMSF) Yes. You often choose the individual funds or ETFs yourself. High. You may hold several PFICs directly inside the wrapper. Generally reportable on both. An SMSF also raises strong foreign grantor trust questions.

The rest of this guide is mostly about categories C and D.

For category A, the IRS's Basic questions and answers on Form 8938 state that payments of foreign social security, or the right to receive them, are not specified foreign financial assets and do not have to be reported. The Form 8938 instructions add a warning: this exclusion does not extend to an interest in a foreign pension plan, which remains reportable under §6038D. Whether the payments are taxed is a separate, treaty-driven question. Under Article 17(3) of the U.S.-UK treaty, social security payments made by one country to a resident of the other "shall be taxable only in that other State," which is the country where the recipient lives. Article 1(5)(a) keeps this rule in force even for U.S. citizens. So the UK State Pension paid to a U.S. resident is taxed only by the United States. Paid to a U.S. citizen living in the UK, it is taxed only by the UK. Neither case involves PFICs or account reporting.

Why a pension's default fund almost always meets the PFIC test

Under IRC §1297(a), a foreign corporation is a PFIC for a year if either of these is true:

  1. Income test: 75% or more of its gross income for the year is passive income.
  2. Asset test: at least 50% of its assets, averaged over the year, produce passive income or are held to produce it.

§1297(b)(1) defines passive income by reference to foreign personal holding company income, which covers dividends, interest, and gains from selling securities. A diversified equity or multi-asset fund earns almost nothing else, and almost everything it owns is a security. So an ordinary non-U.S. mutual fund or ETF that is classified as a corporation meets both tests every year. A pension default fund is built the same way. Being held inside a pension does not change what the fund itself earns or owns.

Does your UK or Australian workplace pension hold a default fund? Under the §1297(a) test, a diversified fund like this meets both the 75% income and 50% asset thresholds almost automatically — being inside a pension wrapper doesn't change that. Find out if your specific fund is a PFIC →

Confirm the legal form of the fund before you conclude. The PFIC rules apply to stock in a foreign corporation.

  • Corporate-form funds. A UK OEIC or an Irish ICAV is normally a foreign "eligible entity" whose members have limited liability. By default, it is therefore classified as an association, which is taxed as a corporation (Treas. Reg. §301.7701-3(b)(2)), and that makes it a potential PFIC. A fund can elect a different classification, and some ICAVs elect to be treated as partnerships. In that case, the PFIC rules don't apply at the fund level.
  • Unit trusts. A unit trust that lets its manager vary the investments is generally a business entity rather than a trust for U.S. purposes (Treas. Reg. §301.7701-4(c)). The default classification just described then applies to it.
  • Insured funds. In contract-based schemes, such as many UK group personal pensions, the "fund" may be a unit-linked fund inside a life insurance policy. That raises different questions about insurance and annuity contracts and may not be a PFIC holding at all.

Get the fund's factsheet and legal documents. Find out whether you hold shares in a company, units in a trust, or rights under an insurance policy.

How a pension makes you an indirect PFIC shareholder

You usually don't own the fund shares yourself. The pension trustee or the insurer does. The PFIC rules reach through the wrapper anyway:

  • Attribution: §1298(a)(3) treats stock owned by a trust, estate, or partnership as owned proportionately by its beneficiaries or partners.
  • Dispositions: under §1298(b)(5), when the entity holding the stock sells it, so that you stop being treated as owning it, the sale is treated as a sale by you. The same applies to distributions the entity receives. The statute says this applies "under regulations," and no final regulations have been issued. But IRS Chief Counsel has taken the position that the provision "is clear on its face and can be applied in the absence of enabling regulations" (CCA 200733024). That memo involved U.S. beneficiaries of a foreign trust.

In practice, a disposition can be triggered by many routine pension events:

  • the scheme automatically switches you out of the growth fund as you near retirement ("lifestyling")
  • you change funds yourself
  • your pot is transferred to a new provider
  • you take benefits

None of these needs to put any cash in your hands.

Step 2: The Canadian counterexample, RRSPs and RRIFs

Canada shows that the PFIC problem is not universal. It also shows exactly how narrow the solution is.

The treaty. Article XVIII(7) of the U.S.-Canada treaty lets a U.S. citizen or resident who is a beneficiary of a Canadian retirement plan elect to defer U.S. tax on income that accrues in the plan until it is distributed. Rev. Proc. 2014-55, §2.02 describes the election as available "subject to rules established by the competent authority."

The IRS procedure. Rev. Proc. 2014-55 made the election automatic for most people:

  • Deemed election. An "eligible individual" who never made a formal election is "treated as having made the election in the first year" in which they could have made it (§4.02). In broad terms, an eligible individual has met their U.S. filing requirements, has not reported the plan's undistributed earnings as income, and has reported distributions as if the election had been made (§4.01).
  • Form 8891 abolished. The Rev. Proc. "obsoletes Form 8891 as of December 31, 2014" (§5.02, §8).
  • No foreign trust reporting. Beneficiaries do not have to report under §6048 (Form 3520), and custodians do not have to file Form 3520-A for a Canadian retirement plan (§5.01). The example in §7 confirms that the taxpayer does not report the RRSP on Form 8891, Form 3520, or Form 3520-A.
  • Other reporting unchanged. The Rev. Proc. does not affect any reporting obligations under §6038D (Form 8938) or other U.S. law, including the FBAR (§5.01). An RRSP or RRIF therefore still counts toward your FBAR and Form 8938 thresholds and must be reported on both if you are over them.
  • Effective dates and history. The Rev. Proc. is effective for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 1996, with §5.01 effective from January 1, 2003. It supersedes Rev. Proc. 2002-23 and Notice 2003-75 (§1, §9).

The PFIC link. Because the treaty says the plan's income is taxed only when distributed, the Form 8621 exception in Treas. Reg. §1.1298-1(c)(4) can apply to Canadian mutual funds held inside an RRSP. That exception covers a member of an arrangement treated as a foreign pension fund under a U.S. income tax treaty, when the treaty provides that the fund's income may be taxed to the member only "when and to the extent the income is paid to" the member or for their benefit.

The lesson. The RRSP result comes from three specific things working together:

  1. a treaty article written for Canadian plans
  2. a Rev. Proc. that names Canadian plans
  3. a regulation that keys off treaty wording

You cannot carry it over to a Swiss pillar 3a account, a French PER, or an Australian super fund by analogy. For any other country, the question is whether that country's treaty contains comparable wording, and whether the IRS has said anything about that country's plans.

Step 3: Australian superannuation, which remains unresolved

Superannuation is the most debated foreign pension in the expat community, and with good reason. Saying clearly what is not known is more useful here than pretending there is an answer.

What the treaty says, and what it leaves out

The U.S.-Australia income tax convention (1982), as amended by the 2001 protocol, has an Article 18 headed "Pensions, Annuities, Alimony and Child Support." According to the Treasury Technical Explanation, that article allocates the right to tax pension payments. It contains no counterpart to UK Article 18(1) or Canadian Article XVIII(7) that would defer U.S. tax on income building up inside a pension fund.

The treaty's saving clause in Article 1(3) lets the United States tax its citizens as if the treaty did not exist. The exceptions to the saving clause listed in Article 1(4) include only paragraphs (2) and (6) of Article 18, which deal with social security payments and with alimony and child support.

What the IRS has and hasn't said

  • No published guidance. We are not aware of any revenue ruling, revenue procedure, or notice classifying Australian superannuation funds for U.S. tax purposes, as of November 2026.
  • Private letter rulings on classification only. In 2015 the IRS released three private letter rulings, PLR 201538006, PLR 201538007, and PLR 201538008. Each concluded that a particular foreign superannuation fund was a trust, not a business entity, under Treas. Reg. §301.7701-4(a). The rulings expressly gave no opinion on any other tax consequence or on treaty benefits. PLRs bind only the taxpayers who requested them and cannot be cited as precedent.
  • One Chief Counsel memo on payments. CCA 200604023 was written in October 2005 and released in January 2006. It explains why the IRS had tentatively planned to rule against a taxpayer, who then withdrew the ruling request. Its conclusion was that a payment the taxpayer received from a deceased member's Australian superannuation fund was subject to U.S. tax under the treaty, because the saving clause lets the United States tax its citizens resident in Australia. It deals with a payment out of a fund, not with how the fund's growth is taxed.

The competing positions

Practitioners generally take one of three approaches. Each leads to a different result for income tax, PFICs, and foreign trust reporting.

  1. Foreign grantor trust. This position is most often taken for SMSFs, where the member is usually a trustee and controls the investments. The member is taxed currently on the fund's income under §§671–679. Any PFICs inside the fund are attributed to the member, and Forms 3520 and 3520-A are in play unless an exemption applies.
  2. Employees' trust under §402(b). This position is often taken for employer-funded industry and retail funds. Vested employer contributions are generally taxable to the employee when made, and the treatment of the fund's earnings depends on how the arrangement is analyzed. It is also debated whether the PFIC attribution rules of §1298(a)(3) reach a participant in such a trust. Some practitioners do not file Form 8621 under this position, while others do as a protective measure. Transfers to §402(b) trusts are excluded from the Form 3520 reportable-event rules (see Step 5).
  3. "Social security" position. This position argues that the compulsory Superannuation Guarantee is the Australian equivalent of Social Security. It relies on the U.S.-Australia Social Security (Totalization) Agreement, which covers Superannuation Guarantee contributions for purposes of deciding which country's system covers a worker. The weakness is that the same agreement's definition of "benefit" excludes benefits under the Superannuation Guarantee, and its benefit provisions do not apply to them. The IRS has not accepted this position in any published guidance.

Have an Australian superannuation fund? Practitioners split between three incompatible positions — foreign grantor trust, employees' trust, or social security — and the IRS has accepted none of them in print as of November 2026. Talk through which position fits your facts →

Litigation and treaty renegotiation

The case most often cited on this point is Alan Dixon's 2019–2020 litigation against the IRS. It did not produce a ruling on the merits. According to reporting by SMSF Adviser, the U.S. Court of Federal Claims dismissed his refund claim on jurisdictional and procedural grounds and did not decide whether his superannuation was exempt as social security.

On the treaty side, advocacy groups have repeatedly asked the Australian Treasury to put superannuation on the agenda for a new protocol (see, for example, the Fix the Tax Treaty submission of October 2021). As of November 2026, we are not aware of any signed or published amending protocol that addresses superannuation. The treaty has not been amended since the 2001 protocol.

What to do with that uncertainty

  • Choose a position and document it. Any position that relies on the treaty should be disclosed on Form 8833 where §6114 requires it.
  • Check whether Rev. Proc. 2020-17 helps with Form 3520 and 3520-A reporting (see Step 5). It does not change income tax or PFIC treatment.
  • Don't skip the FBAR and Form 8938. Nothing about the superannuation debate removes them.

Step 4: UK workplace pensions and SIPPs

UK tax relief has no U.S. effect on its own

UK relief is generous:

None of this is recognized by the Internal Revenue Code. For U.S. purposes, a UK scheme is a foreign arrangement. Absent treaty relief, its investment funds are tested under the PFIC rules like any other foreign funds, and employer contributions can be taxable compensation under §402(b) once they vest.

What the treaty provides, and for whom

The 2001 U.S.-UK treaty, as amended by the 2002 protocol, is much more helpful than the Australian one. But the article you can use depends on where you live.

  • Definition. Article 3(1)(o) defines a "pension scheme" as an arrangement established in a Contracting State that is "generally exempt from income taxation in that State" and is "operated principally to administer or provide pension or retirement benefits." The Exchange of Notes lists the UK schemes covered, together with "any identical or substantially similar schemes" created by later legislation.

  • U.S. residents with a UK pension: Article 18(1). Where a resident of one country is a member of a pension scheme established in the other country, "income earned by the pension scheme may be taxed as income of that individual only when" it is paid out to them (and not merely transferred to another pension scheme). Article 1(5)(a) excludes Article 18(1) from the saving clause, so it protects U.S. citizens who live in the United States. The IRS has read Article 18(1) this way: under Chief Counsel memorandum AM 2008-009, the U.S. may not tax the earnings of a UK scheme until they are distributed to a U.S. resident. Because the wording of Article 18(1) matches the condition in Treas. Reg. §1.1298-1(c)(4), PFICs held inside a qualifying UK scheme generally do not need Form 8621.

  • U.S. citizens living in the UK: Article 18(5). Article 18(1) does not apply here, because the scheme is established in the same country where the person lives. The relevant provision is Article 18(5)(a). It applies where a U.S. citizen resident in the UK works in the UK, the pay is taxable in the UK and borne by a UK employer, and the person is a member of a UK scheme. Contributions paid during that UK employment, and attributable to it, are then deductible or excludable for U.S. purposes. Likewise, "any benefits accrued under the pension scheme, or contributions made to the pension scheme by or on behalf of the individual's employer, during that period, and that are attributable to the employment," are not taxable in the United States. Four limits apply:

    • Relief covers only the period of that UK employment. It does not cover years when you are retired, unemployed, self-employed, or working for a non-UK employer that has no UK establishment, even if you still live in the UK.
    • Relief applies only to the extent the contributions or benefits qualify for UK tax relief.
    • Article 18(5)(b) caps relief at what the United States would allow for a generally corresponding U.S. plan.
    • Article 18(5)(d) requires the U.S. competent authority to have agreed that the scheme generally corresponds to a U.S. plan. The Exchange of Notes treats the listed schemes as meeting this test.

    Article 1(5)(a) also excludes paragraph 5 from the saving clause.

Where the UK analysis is genuinely uncertain

  • Personal SIPPs funded outside employment. For a U.S. citizen living in the UK, a SIPP funded from your own money, rather than through UK employment, does not fit the employment-based wording of Article 18(5)(a). Without treaty cover, the funds inside it are ordinary PFIC holdings.
  • Investment growth in a DC pot. Many practitioners read "benefits accrued" in Article 18(5)(a)(ii) as covering the investment growth of a DC pot. On that reading, they rely on §1.1298-1(c)(4) and do not file Form 8621. The IRS has not published guidance confirming either point, and the wording of Article 18(5) is not the same as the "only when paid" wording that the regulation keys off. Some advisers therefore report the PFICs anyway, or take the treaty position with full Form 8833 disclosure.
  • Contributions above the U.S.-equivalent cap. Contributions or accruals above the 18(5)(b) limit are outside the treaty protection.
  • Gaps in time. Article 18(5) covers only the period of UK employment, and Article 18(1) covers only periods when you live in the United States. A U.S. citizen who stops working in the UK, or who moves to a third country such as France, may be covered by neither article for those years.

Bottom line for the UK. The default fund is generally a PFIC. Whether that costs you anything depends entirely on whether you can rely on a treaty article, and which one. UK tax relief does not decide it.

Step 5: Forms 3520 and 3520-A, and whether your pension is a foreign trust

When a pension is a foreign trust

A pension is a foreign trust for U.S. purposes when two things are true:

  1. It is a trust under Treas. Reg. §301.7701-4(a): trustees hold the assets for beneficiaries who do not share in running a business.
  2. It fails the U.S. court and control tests for domestic trusts, which makes it foreign under §7701(a)(31)(B).

Trust-based UK occupational schemes and master trusts usually meet this description, as do Australian super funds (which the 2015 PLRs above treated as trusts) and SMSFs. Contract-based arrangements, where your rights run against an insurer, may not be trusts at all.

Exceptions to check first

If the pension is a foreign trust, check the exceptions before you treat it as reportable under §6048.

  • Compensatory trusts. §6048(a)(3)(B)(ii) excludes transfers to trusts described in §402(b), §404(a)(4), or §404A from the definition of a reportable event. The Instructions for Form 3520 (Rev. 12-2025) list these as exceptions, along with distributions taxable as compensation for services. This exception is about transfers. If you are treated as the owner of the trust under the grantor trust rules, as is often argued for an SMSF, owner reporting on Form 3520-A is a separate question that this exception does not answer.

  • Canadian plans under Rev. Proc. 2014-55 (Step 2).

  • Rev. Proc. 2020-17. Rev. Proc. 2020-17 exempts an "eligible individual" from §6048 reporting (Forms 3520 and 3520-A) for a "tax-favored foreign retirement trust." Under §5.03, that is a foreign trust established under foreign law and operated exclusively or almost exclusively to provide pension or retirement benefits. It must also meet six conditions:

    1. Tax-favored status: the trust is generally exempt from income tax, or is otherwise tax-favored, under local law. It qualifies if contributions receive a deduction, exclusion, credit, reduced rate, or similar benefit, or if investment income is deferred until distribution or taxed at a reduced rate.
    2. Local information reporting: annual information about the trust or its participants is provided to, or available to, the local tax authorities.
    3. Source of contributions: only contributions from income earned by performing personal services are allowed.
    4. Contribution limits: contributions are limited by a percentage of earned income, to $50,000 or less a year, or to $1,000,000 or less over a lifetime. Amounts are converted at the U.S. Treasury Bureau of the Fiscal Service rate on the last day of the tax year.
    5. Withdrawal restrictions: withdrawals depend on reaching a specified retirement age, disability, or death, or early withdrawals are penalized. Loans and hardship, education, or home-purchase withdrawals do not disqualify the trust.
    6. Nondiscrimination: an employer-maintained trust must be nondiscriminatory. It must cover a wide range of employees, including rank-and-file workers, and provide significant benefits to a substantial majority of eligible employees.

    An eligible individual is a U.S. citizen or resident who is (or comes into) compliance with all U.S. income tax return filing requirements, and who has reported contributions, earnings, and distributions as required. Relief under the Rev. Proc. is effective March 16, 2020, and applies to open years. It also provides a procedure for abatement or refund of penalties already assessed under §6677.

  • Proposed Treas. Reg. §1.6048-5 (May 2024). The proposed regulations loosen condition 4. A trust can meet either a value threshold, under which the aggregate value of such trusts is "no more than $600,000 at any point during the taxable year," or a contribution limit: a percentage of earned income, $75,000 a year, or $1,000,000 over a lifetime. From 2025 onward, the dollar amounts are indexed in the same way as the §415(d) limits. The regulations also allow limited contributions of unearned income and add a new "de minimis savings trust" category. The Form 3520 instructions say you may rely on these proposed rules for tax years ending after May 8, 2024, if you apply them consistently and in their entirety.

What none of these exemptions change

The Form 3520 instructions state that the exemptions in Rev. Proc. 2014-55, Rev. Proc. 2020-17, and the proposed regulations do not affect any other reporting obligation. The Form 8938 instructions say the same about Rev. Proc. 2020-17 and §6038D. You still file the FBAR and Form 8938. The exemptions also do not change how you are taxed. Whether you owe income tax on contributions or growth, and whether you have PFIC exposure, is a separate question.

If no exemption applies

The stakes are high. §6677 imposes a penalty of the greater of $10,000 or 35% of the gross reportable amount, or 5% for a U.S. owner's failure to ensure that Form 3520-A is filed. Go to our Form 3520-A guide for the filing mechanics. We don't repeat them here.

Step 6: FBAR and Form 8938, two different tests

FBAR (FinCEN Form 114)

Who must file. Under 31 CFR §1010.350, a U.S. person must report foreign accounts in which they have a financial interest, or over which they have signature or other authority. The report is required only if the accounts' combined value exceeds $10,000 at any time during the calendar year (31 CFR §1010.306(c)). The threshold is not indexed. It applied unchanged for calendar year 2025. That FBAR was due April 15, 2026, with an automatic extension to October 15, 2026 (IRS fact sheet FS-2022-24).

Why a DC pension is almost always reportable.

  • No foreign-plan exception. The only retirement exceptions in the regulation are for IRAs under IRC §§408 and 408A and for tax-qualified plans under §§401(a), 403(a), and 403(b), as FS-2022-24 summarizes. All of them are U.S. plans. No exception exists for foreign pensions.
  • The definition is broad. The regulation's definition of "other financial account" includes cash-value insurance and annuity policies and holdings in mutual funds or similar pooled funds.
  • Trusts are covered. Its definition of "financial interest" covers a trust that you own for U.S. tax purposes as grantor, and a trust in which you have "a present beneficial interest in more than 50 percent of the assets" or from which you receive more than 50% of the current income (§1010.350(e)(2)(iii)–(iv)).

The exact rule that captures a given pension varies with how it is structured. The conservative and common practice is to report every DC pension account and SIPP, and to count it toward the $10,000 threshold. A state pension with no account (category A) is not a financial account. A pure defined benefit entitlement (category B) is less clear-cut, and practice varies.

Form 8938 (FATCA, §6038D)

Thresholds. The Form 8938 instructions (Rev. November 2021) are the continuous-use version that still applies to tax year 2025. For taxpayers who meet the presence-abroad test, they set these thresholds:

Filing status (living abroad) Value on last day of tax year Value at any time during the year
Single or married filing separately More than $200,000 More than $300,000
Married filing jointly More than $400,000 More than $600,000

A foreign pension is reportable. The IRS Form 8938 Q&A confirms that an interest in a foreign pension or deferred compensation plan must be reported if you are over your threshold.

Part V or Part VI: an often-confused distinction. Form 8938 has two detail sections:

  • Part V is "Detailed Information for Each Foreign Deposit and Custodial Account."
  • Part VI is "Detailed Information for Each 'Other Foreign Asset.'"

The instructions handle pensions in two places:

  • Under Interests in Foreign Pension Plans and Foreign Deferred Compensation Plans, they say: "Report in Part VI your interest in the foreign pension plan or foreign deferred compensation plan. Do not separately report the assets held by the plan."
  • A separate caution says that "you must report retirement and pension accounts" that are excluded from the FATCA financial account definition used by foreign financial institutions.

Our reading of these two passages, which the instructions do not spell out in one place: an interest in a pension plan, whether an employer scheme, a master trust, or a super fund, goes in Part VI as a single asset, and you do not list the funds inside it. A retirement account that is itself a depository or custodial account maintained by a foreign financial institution, such as some platform-held personal pensions, goes in Part V. When in doubt, look at the legal form: a member interest in a plan, or a custodial account held in your name.

Valuation. Treas. Reg. §1.6038D-5(f)(3) and the instructions set the order:

  1. The value is the fair market value of your beneficial interest on the last day of the year.
  2. If you don't know that value and have no readily accessible way to find it, use the value of cash and property distributed to you during the year.
  3. If there were no distributions either, use zero.

No double reporting. If you report your interest in the pension trust on a timely Form 3520, you don't report it again in detail on Form 8938. Instead, you identify the Form 3520 in Part IV. The instructions say you must still "include the value of all specified foreign financial assets, even if they are reported on another form listed in Part IV" when you test your threshold. If Rev. Proc. 2020-17 removes the Form 3520, the pension goes back onto Form 8938 in full.

No tax return, no Form 8938. Form 8938 is attached to the income tax return. According to the IRS Q&A, if you are not required to file a return for the year, you don't file Form 8938 either. The FBAR has no such exception.

The three obligations side by side

FBAR (FinCEN 114) Form 8938 Form 3520 / 3520-A
Authority 31 U.S.C. §5314; 31 CFR §1010.350 IRC §6038D IRC §6048
Filed with FinCEN (BSA E-Filing) IRS, attached to Form 1040 IRS, separately
Threshold (2025) Over $10,000 aggregate at any time $200,000 / $300,000 single abroad; $400,000 / $600,000 joint abroad No dollar threshold for owners; event-based for transferors and beneficiaries
Foreign pension exception? None Only foreign social security §402(b)/§404(a)(4)/§404A trusts; Canadian plans; Rev. Proc. 2020-17; proposed §1.6048-5
Affected by Rev. Proc. 2020-17? No No Yes

Worked example: a UK auto-enrolment pension invested in the default fund

This example shows what the excess distribution regime of §1291 costs when it applies to recurring pension contributions rather than a single purchase. It uses the same method as our general PFIC guide. It is deliberately the downside case: it assumes no treaty relief shields the fund's growth. That could be because the member does not qualify under Article 18(5), or because, on advice, they chose not to rely on it.

Assumptions

  • Facts: a U.S. citizen lives and works in the UK and is auto-enrolled into a master trust (a trust-based multi-employer scheme) from July 2018. The default fund is an OEIC classified as a corporation for U.S. purposes, so it is a PFIC.
  • Contributions: employee plus employer, equal to $8,000 a year. For simplicity, they are made as one payment on July 1 of each year, 2018 through 2024. That makes seven purchases, or "lots," and $56,000 contributed in total. In real life, monthly contributions create 12 lots a year, each calculated separately.
  • Taxed when made: the contributions were included in U.S. income when made, so U.S. basis equals $56,000.
  • Growth: the fund returns 6% a year, and its accumulation units distribute nothing.
  • Disposition: on July 1, 2025, the member moves to a new employer and the pot is transferred to a new provider. The old scheme sells all the default fund units. That is a disposition attributed to the member under §1298(b)(5), and it falls in tax year 2025.
  • No elections: neither a QEF nor a mark-to-market election was ever made.
  • Currency: all amounts are in U.S. dollars. In a real calculation, each lot's basis and proceeds are converted at the exchange rates on the relevant dates, so currency movements change the gain.

The mechanics under §1291

  1. The whole gain is an excess distribution. Under §1291(a)(2), the gain on each lot is treated as an excess distribution.
  2. Spread it over the days you held the lot. Under §1291(a)(1)(A), each lot's gain is allocated ratably to each day of that lot's holding period.
  3. The current year is ordinary income. The share allocated to 2025, the year of the sale, is ordinary income for 2025. It is not capital gain, and since it is not earned income, the foreign earned income exclusion under §911 does not cover it.
  4. Earlier years are taxed at the top rate. Under §1291(c)(2), the share allocated to each earlier year is taxed at the highest rate in effect for that year: 37% for 2018–2025 under §1(j). This applies whatever your actual bracket was.
  5. Interest is added. Under §1291(c)(3), interest is charged on each year's tax at the §6621 underpayment rate, compounded daily. It runs from the original due date of that year's return (April 15 of the following year) to the original due date of the 2025 return, April 15, 2026, in both cases ignoring extensions.

The underpayment rates used, from the IRS quarterly table:

Year Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2019 6% 6% 5% 5%
2020 5% 5% 3% 3%
2021 3% 3% 3% 3%
2022 3% 4% 5% 6%
2023 7% 7% 7% 8%
2024 8% 8% 8% 8%
2025 7% 7% 7% 7%
2026 7% 6% — —

Step by step for one lot: the July 2018 contribution

  • Gain. $8,000 grows to $12,029 by July 1, 2025, a gain of $4,029.
  • Holding period. 2,557 days, from July 2, 2018 through July 1, 2025.
  • Daily allocation. $4,029 ÷ 2,557 days ≈ $1.58 a day:
    • 2018 (183 days): $288
    • 2019, 2021, 2022, 2023 (365 days each): $575 each
    • 2020 and 2024 (366 days each): $577 each
    • 2025 (182 days): $287
  • Current year. The $287 allocated to 2025 is ordinary income on the 2025 return.
  • Earlier years. The $3,742 allocated to 2018–2024 is taxed at 37%, for $1,385 of "deferred tax."
  • Interest. Interest on the deferred tax totals $386. The tax allocated to 2018 accrues the most: about 48.4% compound interest from April 15, 2019 to April 15, 2026.

All seven lots

Lot (July 1) Contributed Value 7/1/2025 Gain 2025 ordinary income Deferred tax (37%) Interest
2018 $8,000 $12,029 $4,029 $287 $1,385 $386
2019 $8,000 $11,348 $3,348 $278 $1,136 $282
2020 $8,000 $10,706 $2,706 $270 $901 $196
2021 $8,000 $10,100 $2,100 $262 $680 $124
2022 $8,000 $9,528 $1,528 $254 $472 $67
2023 $8,000 $8,989 $989 $246 $275 $28
2024 $8,000 $8,480 $480 $239 $89 $6
Total $56,000 $71,180 $15,180 $1,835 $4,937 $1,089

Figures rounded to the nearest dollar, so rows may not add exactly.

What the member owes for tax year 2025

Component Amount
Deferred tax on amounts allocated to 2018–2024 $4,937
Interest on the deferred tax $1,089
Tax on $1,835 of 2025 ordinary income (assuming a 24% marginal rate) $440
Total U.S. cost of the transfer ≈ $6,467

That is about 43% of the $15,180 gain, triggered by a pension transfer that put no cash in the member's hands. Compare it with two other cases:

  • The same money in a 401(k): $0 of U.S. tax until it is actually distributed.
  • The same gain on a U.S.-domiciled fund in a taxable account: about $2,277 at a 15% long-term capital gains rate.

A transfer between UK registered schemes is generally not taxed in the UK, so there is no UK tax to credit against the U.S. bill.

Three things make the real-world result worse:

  • More lots. Monthly contributions mean dozens or hundreds of lots, each calculated separately.
  • More funds. Lifestyling usually moves the pot through several funds over the years, and each sale is another disposition.
  • Annual Form 8621. Form 8621 is due every year for each PFIC. The $25,000 de minimis exception in §1.1298-1(c)(2) is not available in a year with an excess distribution, as in 2025 here.

If treaty relief does apply, the U.S. cost of the 2025 transfer is generally $0. For this member, that would mean Article 18(5), on the reading discussed above. For a U.S. resident, it would mean Article 18(1), whose text treats a transfer to another pension scheme as not being a payment. That gap, between $0 and about $6,467, is why the treaty analysis matters so much more than the UK tax relief.

Changing pension providers, or about to? In this example, the same transfer costs $0 with treaty relief and about $6,467 (43% of the gain) without it — and it puts no cash in your hands to pay that bill. Check whether your treaty protects your transfer →

Common mistakes

  • Assuming a workplace pension is a 401(k) for the IRS. The Code recognizes U.S. plans. Foreign plans get deferral only through specific treaty articles or IRS guidance, and only for the people and plan types those provisions name.
  • Not looking inside the pension. Concluding there is "nothing to report" without checking what the pension holds is a common error. If it holds non-U.S. pooled funds, check their legal form and their PFIC status.
  • Treating one form as enough. The FBAR, Form 8938, and Forms 3520/3520-A have different definitions and exceptions. Rev. Proc. 2020-17 removes only Forms 3520 and 3520-A. Rev. Proc. 2014-55 removes Forms 8891, 3520, and 3520-A for Canadian plans, but neither the FBAR nor Form 8938.
  • Applying the RRSP treatment to another country. Article XVIII(7) and Rev. Proc. 2014-55 are specific to Canada. For any other country, read that country's treaty, check its saving clause and the exceptions to it, and look for country-specific IRS guidance.
  • Assuming the UK treaty works the same for everyone. Article 18(1) protects U.S. residents with UK schemes. U.S. citizens living in the UK depend on Article 18(5), which is narrower and covers employment-based schemes only.
  • Overlooking events inside the pension. Fund switches, lifestyling, and provider transfers can be PFIC dispositions under §1298(b)(5) even though you never receive any money.
  • Not disclosing treaty positions. Relying on Article 18 or another treaty article to override the Code generally requires Form 8833 under §6114.

FAQ

Is my UK State Pension a PFIC, or reportable on Form 8938 or the FBAR?

No. A state pension gives you a right to future benefits, not an account or fund units, so there is nothing to test under the PFIC rules. The IRS says foreign social security is not a specified foreign financial asset for Form 8938. It is not a financial account for the FBAR either. The payments themselves are taxed only in your country of residence under Article 17(3) of the U.S.-UK treaty. That means only the U.S. taxes them if you live in the U.S., and only the UK taxes them if you are a U.S. citizen living in the UK.

Does Rev. Proc. 2020-17 mean I don't have to report my foreign pension?

No. It exempts qualifying plans from Forms 3520 and 3520-A only. The IRS states that it does not affect Form 8938 or the FBAR, and it does not change how you are taxed on contributions, growth, or PFICs inside the plan.

My pension provider says the plan is tax-free in my country. Doesn't that settle it?

No. Local tax-favored status is one condition for the Rev. Proc. 2020-17 reporting exemption. It has no effect on U.S. income tax or PFIC treatment unless a treaty article gives you deferral.

Do I need Form 8621 for funds inside my RRSP?

Generally not. The Article XVIII(7) election, deemed made under Rev. Proc. 2014-55, defers U.S. tax on income accruing in the plan. Treas. Reg. §1.1298-1(c)(4) excuses Form 8621 for PFICs held through a treaty-recognized pension fund whose income is taxable only when paid out.

Has the IRS ruled on how Australian superannuation is taxed?

Not in any published guidance, as of November 2026. The only IRS documents are private letter rulings from 2015 that classified particular funds as trusts and gave no other conclusions, and a 2005 Chief Counsel memo holding a payment taxable to a U.S. citizen. The Dixon litigation was dismissed on procedural grounds without a ruling on the merits.

Where do I report my pension on Form 8938, Part V or Part VI?

An interest in a pension plan goes in Part VI as one asset, without listing the funds inside it, as the instructions direct. Part V is for depository and custodial accounts. A retirement account that is itself a custodial account at a foreign financial institution belongs in Part V.

What value do I use for a pension on Form 8938?

Use the fair market value of your beneficial interest on the last day of the year. If you have no readily accessible way to find that value, use the value of distributions you received during the year. If there were none, use zero.

Is a fund switch inside my pension really a taxable PFIC event?

It can be. Under §1298(b)(5), a sale of PFIC stock by the entity that holds it on your behalf is treated as a disposition by you. With no treaty relief and no election in place, the gain is taxed under §1291, as in the example above.

Sources

Primary sources

Secondary sources

This article is general information about U.S. federal tax and reporting rules as of November 2026, based on the sources cited. It is not tax or legal advice. How foreign pensions are treated depends on the plan's legal structure, the applicable treaty, your residence and citizenship, and elections and positions taken in earlier years. Several of the points discussed, including Australian superannuation and how far UK Article 18(5) reaches, are not settled by IRS guidance. Consult a qualified cross-border tax professional before filing or changing a return position.

↑ Back to key takeawaysBack to top

Test TaxLatitude on this type of case

Analyze your case in minutes.

Create an accountAll articles

Get the next articles by email

You will receive a confirmation link first; nothing is sent until you open it. Privacy details and unsubscribe: unsubscribe page.