Figures and legal status verified November 11, 2026. These regimes change often, so check the date on any number you rely on.
Italy, Greece, and the United Kingdom all offer special regimes for wealthy newcomers. Local advisers often pitch them as a way to pay a fixed sum, or nothing at all, on foreign income. For a U.S. citizen or green card holder, that pitch leaves out the other side of the ledger: the IRS. This article explains why, regime by regime. It also looks closely at the hardest technical question, which is whether a fixed lump-sum tax counts as a creditable foreign income tax at all.
We assume you already know what a saving clause is and how the foreign tax credit limitation works by category. If not, start with our guides on how to read a U.S. tax treaty and foreign tax credit limits.
Key takeaways
- The U.S. taxes you first, regardless of where you live. U.S. citizens and resident aliens are taxed on worldwide income under IRC §1 and §61, and Treas. Reg. §1.1-1(b) applies this to citizens "wherever resident." A foreign regime cannot change that.
- The treaty won't get you out. The U.S. treaties with Italy (Art. 1(2)), Greece (Art. XIV(1)), and the United Kingdom (Art. 1(4)) each contain a saving clause that preserves U.S. taxation of citizens.
- The 2026 prices are €300,000 in Italy, €100,000 in Greece, and £0 in the UK. Italy's lump sum went up to €300,000 a year for people moving in from January 1, 2026. Greece's stays at €100,000 a year. The UK replaced its non-dom regime on April 6, 2025 with a four-year exemption for foreign income and gains (the FIG regime).
- Whether a lump sum is creditable is unresolved. A fixed charge almost certainly fails the net-income test of Treas. Reg. §1.901-2. Whether it qualifies as a tax "in lieu of" an income tax under §903 is arguable either way, and we found no IRS ruling or court decision on point.
- Even a creditable lump sum only goes so far. For a typical American investor, most portfolio income is U.S.-source, and a foreign tax credit cannot reduce U.S. tax on U.S.-source income. At best, your total bill ends up roughly equal to your U.S. tax alone.
- Some taxes are never reduced. The 3.8% net investment income tax, self-employment tax, and state income tax (if you remain domiciled in a state) are not reduced by any of these regimes or by the foreign tax credit.
The U.S. side: two locks a local adviser rarely checks
Lock 1: citizenship-based taxation is the default rule
IRC §1 imposes the income tax on the income of every individual who is a U.S. citizen or resident (Treas. Reg. §1.1-1(a)(1)), and IRC §61 defines gross income as income "from whatever source derived." The regulations spell out the consequence: Treas. Reg. §1.1-1(b) says that all U.S. citizens, wherever resident, and all resident aliens are liable for U.S. income tax on income from sources within or without the United States. The Supreme Court upheld taxing a nonresident citizen's foreign income a century ago in Cook v. Tait, 265 U.S. 47 (1924).
This rule exists before and apart from any treaty. An Italian, Greek, or British regime changes how much that country taxes you. It has no effect on whether the U.S. taxes you.
Lock 2: the saving clause keeps the treaty from undoing Lock 1
A U.S. citizen generally cannot use a treaty to escape U.S. tax, because each treaty reserves the U.S. right to tax its citizens as if the treaty did not exist. We cover this in depth in how to read a U.S. tax treaty. Here are the specific provisions for the three countries:
| Country | Treaty | Saving clause | Exceptions that survive | U.S. credit provision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Italy | Convention signed August 25, 1999 | Art. 1(2) | Art. 1(3)(a), including Art. 23 (relief from double taxation) | Art. 23(2)(a); special rules for U.S. citizens resident in Italy in Art. 23(4) |
| Greece | Convention signed February 20, 1950 (protocol 1953) | Art. XIV(1) | None listed: Art. XIV(1) applies "notwithstanding any provision" of the convention, and the credit comes from Art. XIV(2) itself | Art. XIV(2), "subject to section 131" of the 1939 Code (the predecessor of §901) |
| United Kingdom | Convention signed July 24, 2001, as amended by the 2002 protocol | Art. 1(4) | Art. 1(5), including Art. 24 | Art. 24(1); citizen rules in Art. 24(6) |
The treaty's main surviving benefit for a citizen is the credit article, and every credit article in this table depends on U.S. law. Italy's Article 23(2)(a) grants the credit "in accordance with the provisions and subject to the limitations of" U.S. law (Treasury Technical Explanation). The UK's Article 24(1) opens with the same words (treaty text, legislation.gov.uk). Greece's Article XIV(2) ties the credit to the Code section that is now §901. So the treaty sends you back to the Code's definition of a creditable tax, which is the subject of the section on creditability below.
Where each regime stands in November 2026
Italy: the new-resident flat tax (art. 24-bis TUIR)
- Amount. The lump sum is a fixed €300,000 per tax year, owed regardless of how much foreign income you have. Each family member who joins pays €50,000. The 2026 Budget Law (Law No. 199 of December 30, 2025, art. 1, paragraphs 25–26, Official Gazette extract; Gazzetta Ufficiale no. 301, Suppl. Ord. no. 42) raised these amounts from €200,000 and €25,000. Under paragraph 26, the increase applies to people who transfer their civil-law residence (art. 43 of the Civil Code) to Italy from the date the law took effect, January 1, 2026 (DWF summary).
- Earlier arrivals keep their earlier amount. The fee was €100,000 when the regime started in 2017. It rose to €200,000 under Decree-Law 113/2024 for people who moved after that decree took effect in August 2024. Then it rose to €300,000 from 2026 (brocardi.it consolidated text and notes).
- Eligibility. You must not have been tax resident in Italy for at least nine of the ten tax years before the option takes effect (art. 24-bis(1); Agenzia delle Entrate check-list instructions). The statute says the option is exercised after a favorable ruling (interpello) from the Agenzia delle Entrate (art. 24-bis(3)). However, the Agenzia's implementing measure of March 8, 2017 treats the ruling request as optional and also allows the election in the tax return (Provvedimento, §§1.2 and 1.12). Italian commentators have pointed out that this does not match the statute (Eutekne/EC News).
- Duration and loss of the benefit. The option is revocable and ends no later than fifteen years after its first year. It also ends if you fail to pay the lump sum or pay only part of it. Once you revoke the option or lose it, you can never elect it again (art. 24-bis(4)).
- Carve-outs that matter to Americans. Gains on qualified shareholdings realized in the first five years stay under ordinary Italian taxation (art. 24-bis(1)). You may also exclude one or more countries from the regime. Income from an excluded country is then taxed under ordinary rules, with an Italian foreign tax credit (art. 24-bis(5)). Italian-source income is always taxed normally.
Greece: the non-dom lump sum (art. 5A, Law 4172/2013)
- Amount. You pay a flat €100,000 per tax year on foreign-source income, regardless of how much of it there is, plus €20,000 for each relative who joins. A relative means a spouse or a direct ascendant or descendant. The Greek tax authority (AADE) confirmed both amounts again in a July 20, 2026 press release announcing a simpler application procedure.
- Eligibility. You must not have been Greek tax resident in at least seven of the eight years before you move. You must also invest at least €500,000 in Greek real estate, businesses, or securities within three years of applying. Holders of a Greek investment residence permit (the "Golden Visa") are exempt from the investment requirement (AADE guide, November 12, 2025).
- Duration and loss of the benefit. The regime lasts fifteen tax years and cannot be extended. If you fail to pay the full lump sum, the regime ends from that year and you are taxed on worldwide income. If the investment turns out to be incomplete after three years, the regime is cancelled retroactively from the year you entered it (AADE guide).
- Scope. Covered foreign income does not have to be declared in Greece. Greek-source income remains taxable under the general rules.
United Kingdom: non-dom abolished, four-year FIG regime in its place
- The old regime is gone. From April 6, 2025, all UK residents are taxed on the arising basis on their worldwide income and gains. The remittance basis that non-doms relied on no longer exists.
- The replacement. The FIG regime gives a "qualifying new resident" relief from UK tax on foreign income and gains for up to four consecutive tax years, starting with the year they become UK resident. The government described this as 100% relief on eligible foreign income and gains. To qualify, you must have been non-UK resident for at least the ten consecutive tax years before arrival. Members of the House of Commons and the House of Lords are excluded.
- Conditions. You must claim the relief separately for each year and each source, on the SA109 pages of the return (HMRC HS266, updated May 18, 2026). Years you don't claim still count toward the four, and unused years cannot be carried forward.
- What claiming costs you. A claim removes your personal allowance and the capital gains tax annual exempt amount. You can't use foreign losses in a claim year. You can't claim UK foreign tax credit relief on relieved income (HS266).
- Not covered. Foreign employment income is not covered by the FIG claim; Overseas Workday Relief may apply to it instead (HS266).
Side-by-side
| Italy (art. 24-bis) | Greece (art. 5A) | UK (FIG regime) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual local cost on foreign income | €300,000 (arrivals from Jan. 1, 2026) | €100,000 | £0 (relief, not a charge) |
| Per family member | €50,000 | €20,000 | Individual claims |
| Prior non-residence | 9 of 10 years | 7 of 8 years | 10 consecutive years |
| Maximum duration | 15 years | 15 years | 4 tax years |
| Investment requirement | None | €500,000 (or Golden Visa) | None |
| Main ways to lose it | Non-payment; revocation (final) | Non-payment; investment not completed (retroactive) | Claim not made; window runs out |
| Local tax to credit on the U.S. return | Fixed lump sum (creditability uncertain) | Fixed lump sum (creditability uncertain) | None on relieved income |
The UK row is the simplest to analyze. If Britain charges no tax on your foreign income, there is nothing to credit. You pay full U.S. tax on that income. The Italian and Greek rows raise a harder question.
Weighing Italy's flat tax against Greece's non-dom regime? The local sticker price looks simple, but whether either country's lump sum even counts as a creditable tax on your U.S. return is a separate, unresolved question. Model your actual numbers →
Is a fixed lump-sum tax creditable?
This is the point most likely to be overstated in either direction. Here is what the rules say, and where they leave the question open.
Which rules apply
A foreign levy is creditable only if it is either a net income tax under Treas. Reg. §1.901-2 or a tax in lieu of an income tax under Treas. Reg. §1.903-1 (IRS Publication 514).
Final regulations issued in January 2022 tightened both tests. In Notice 2023-55, the IRS let taxpayers apply the pre-2022 version of §1.901-2(a) and (b) instead. The same notice lets them apply the current §1.903-1 without its "jurisdiction to tax excluded income" requirement. The relief is optional, but a taxpayer who uses it must apply it consistently to all foreign taxes for that year (Weil summary). Notice 2023-80 extended this relief until further guidance is issued. We found no notice withdrawing it as of this writing. Note that the relief does not restore the old §903 regulation: the current §1.903-1 substitution test still applies.
Each levy is tested separately. Italy's ordinary tax on your Italian-source income is a different levy from the 24-bis lump sum, and the two are judged independently (§1.901-2(d)).
As a net income tax: very likely no
Under the current regulation, a levy is a net income tax only if it meets the net gain requirement, which looks at realization, gross receipts, and cost recovery (§1.901-2(a)(3), (b)). The pre-2022 version, which Notice 2023-55 allows you to use, applies a looser "predominant character" test, but that test still requires the tax to be likely to reach net gain in the normal circumstances in which it applies (RSM summary). The Italian statute says the opposite: the tax is computed as a lump sum "a prescindere dall'importo dei redditi percepiti" (regardless of the income received) (art. 24-bis(2)). The Greek amount is likewise owed "ανεξαρτήτως του ύψους αυτού" (regardless of how much foreign income there is) (AADE). A charge with no base cannot meet a test that looks at the base. We are not aware of any credible argument that these lump sums are net income taxes.
As a tax "in lieu of" an income tax: genuinely arguable
Section 903 treats a tax paid "in lieu of" a generally imposed income tax as creditable. The current regulation does not require the base of an in-lieu tax to resemble income: §1.903-1(b)(1) says "it is immaterial whether the base of the in lieu of tax bears any relation to realized net gain" (text via Tax Notes). What it does require is a "substitution requirement" with several parts (§1.903-1(c)(1)):
- The same country must generally impose a net income tax. Italy's IRPEF and Greece's income tax both qualify.
- Non-duplication. Neither that income tax nor any other net income tax may also apply to the excluded income of anyone subject to the tested tax.
- Close connection. The country must have made a "cognizant and deliberate choice" to impose the tested tax instead of its income tax, shown through foreign law or legislative history.
- Jurisdiction to tax excluded income. The regulation has a fourth, attribution-type requirement, but Notice 2023-55 lets you disregard it while the relief remains in effect.
Arguments that the lump sum qualifies:
- Italy labels the lump sum an imposta sostitutiva dell'IRPEF (a substitute for its income tax), and the statute takes the covered foreign income out of the ordinary income tax (art. 24-bis). That looks like exactly the deliberate substitution the close-connection test asks for.
- Greece says that paying the lump sum fully satisfies the tax obligation on the foreign income (AADE).
- The regulation expressly says the base doesn't have to look like income.
Arguments that it does not qualify:
- The regulation's structure assumes the tested tax has a base (its own examples are sales or units of production) that relates to the "excluded income." A fixed sum that does not vary with anything has no base, which makes the required link to excluded income hard to establish.
- The charge is elective and works more like the price of a residence status than a tax on income. Under §1.901-2(a), a levy must first be a "tax" at all to be creditable.
- If your ordinary Italian or Greek tax would have been lower than the lump sum, the noncompulsory-payment rules in §1.901-2(e)(5) may limit any credit. Those rules cover foreign-law elections and choices between alternative levies.
- A separate question is whether the lump sum is a "covered tax" under each treaty. The Italian treaty covers IRPEF and substantially similar later taxes. The 1950 Greek treaty lists the Greek income tax, including its schedular and complementary components, as they existed then (Art. I). Whether a fixed charge is "substantially similar" to a progressive income tax is untested.
Our assessment. We found no published IRS ruling, regulation example, notice, or court decision on whether Italy's art. 24-bis tax, Greece's art. 5A tax, or any comparable fixed lump sum is creditable. A recent practitioner analysis reached the same conclusion (US-UK Tax, October 2026). On the current record, the honest answer is that creditability is uncertain. You should model both outcomes. If you claim the credit, you should be prepared to support the §903 position in an audit. Also, §903 extends in-lieu treatment to the deduction for foreign taxes under §164(a) too (§903). So a levy that fails §903 does not become deductible as a foreign income tax instead.
Planning to claim a foreign tax credit for your Italian or Greek lump sum? No IRS ruling has ever confirmed it qualifies — if you claim it, you're taking a position you may have to defend in an audit, not a settled deduction. Check where you'd stand →
Even if it is creditable, the credit is smaller than it looks
Suppose the IRS accepts the lump sum as a §903 tax. Two more limits apply.
- Source. Dividends from U.S. corporations and interest from U.S. payers are U.S.-source income. Capital gains need closer attention. Under §865(g)(2), a U.S. citizen with a foreign tax home is not treated as a nonresident on a sale of personal property unless a foreign income tax of at least 10% of the gain is actually paid. A fixed lump sum that does not attach to any particular gain makes that 10% test hard to meet. In that case, gains on your U.S. brokerage portfolio are probably U.S.-source.
- Limitation. The credit can only offset U.S. tax on foreign-source income (§904; see our foreign tax credit limits guide). The part of the lump sum attributable to U.S.-source income produces no credit at all. The Italy treaty has a resourcing rule for U.S. citizens resident in Italy (Art. 23(4)(c)). However, it applies only to Italian taxes that count as income taxes under the treaty, and it was designed around Italy computing a credit on specific items of income. Whether it works for a lump sum that is not computed by reference to any item is untested.
What these regimes actually reduce
The real benefits are on the local side, and for wealthy families some of them have nothing to do with income tax:
- Local income tax on foreign income. This is the core benefit in all three countries. Italy and Greece replace the local tax with a lump sum; the UK relieves it entirely for up to four years.
- Italian wealth taxes and reporting. People on the art. 24-bis regime are exempt from Italy's taxes on foreign real estate (IVIE) and foreign financial assets (IVAFE) and from the foreign-asset reporting obligation (quadro RW) (Agenzia delle Entrate, Circular 17/E of May 23, 2017, §5.2).
- Local inheritance and gift tax on foreign assets. In Italy, inheritance and gift tax applies only to assets located in Italy while the option is in force (Law 232/2016, art. 1(158); Circular 17/E, §5.3). Greece similarly exempts foreign movable property from Greek inheritance and gift tax under art. 5A (AADE).
None of these local exemptions affects your U.S. obligations. The U.S. estate tax still reaches a citizen's property "wherever situated" (IRC §2031(a)). You still have to file the FBAR (31 C.F.R. §1010.350) and Form 8938 (IRC §6038D) even if Italy no longer requires you to report foreign assets.
What these regimes never reduce
The net investment income tax
The 3.8% NIIT applies to the lesser of net investment income or modified AGI above a threshold. That threshold is $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for joint filers, and the amounts are fixed in the statute (IRC §1411). It applies to U.S. citizens abroad; for individuals, the only exclusion is for nonresident aliens.
The NIIT sits in chapter 2A of the Code, outside the chapter 1 taxes that the foreign tax credit offsets (analysis of the Federal Circuit's reasoning). On August 31, 2026, the Federal Circuit held in Christensen v. United States (France treaty) and Estate of Bruyea v. United States (Canada treaty) that treaty-based foreign tax credits cannot offset the NIIT. Both decisions reversed taxpayer wins in the Court of Federal Claims (KPMG summary; RSM analysis). The Tax Court had reached the same result in Toulouse v. Commissioner, 157 T.C. 49 (2021).
Those cases did not involve the Italian, Greek, or UK treaties. But all three credit articles are expressly made subject to U.S. law (see the treaty table above), and the Federal Circuit relied on that kind of language. The taxpayers in those cases could still seek further review, so check the current status before relying on them. Either way, a lump-sum regime cannot change this outcome.
Self-employment tax
Self-employment tax under IRC §1401 is a chapter 2 tax, so the foreign tax credit does not reduce it. What can eliminate it is a totalization agreement, and none of these tax regimes affects which country covers you:
- UK: a self-employed person residing in the UK is assigned UK coverage. You need a UK certificate of coverage to establish the U.S. exemption.
- Greece: coverage follows residence, so self-employed residents of Greece are assigned Greek coverage.
- Italy: the agreement is different. According to SSA's summary, a self-employed U.S. national who would otherwise be covered by both systems is covered only by U.S. Social Security. An American consultant living in Milan on the flat tax should therefore expect to keep paying U.S. self-employment tax.
Self-employed and considering Italy's flat tax? The U.S.-Italy totalization agreement still assigns you to U.S. Social Security coverage, so the flat tax does nothing to stop your self-employment tax bill. See what the flat tax actually changes for you →
State income tax
If you never broke domicile in a state that taxes its residents on worldwide income, that state can still tax you, and the state has no saving clause to negotiate around. A foreign regime has no effect on state tax. See our guide on state taxes after moving abroad.
Worked example: a $4 million investor moves to Milan in 2026
Facts. Claire is a single U.S. citizen. She moves to Milan in January 2026 and elects the art. 24-bis regime at €300,000, with no family members. All of her 2026 income comes from outside Italy:
| Income item (2026) | Amount | U.S. source? |
|---|---|---|
| Qualified dividends, U.S. companies | $1,000,000 | U.S. |
| Interest, U.S. bank and Treasury holdings | $800,000 | U.S. |
| Long-term gains, sale of U.S.-listed stock | $1,200,000 | U.S. (per §865(g)(2), see above) |
| Qualified dividends, UK-listed companies (no UK withholding) | $1,000,000 | Foreign |
| Total | $4,000,000 |
For illustration we convert at €1 = $1.16, roughly the 2026 average to date (Pound Sterling Live, 2026 EUR/USD history). At that rate the lump sum is $348,000.
The local pitch. €300,000 on about €3.45 million of income is an effective rate of 8.7%.
U.S. tax before any credit (2026 rules, Rev. Proc. 2025-32).
- Standard deduction: $16,100. Taxable income: $3,983,900.
- Ordinary portion: $783,900 of interest after the deduction. Tax at the 2026 single brackets, with the 37% rate starting above $640,600: $246,000.
- Qualified dividends and long-term gains: $3,200,000, all above the $545,500 threshold for the 20% rate. Tax: $640,000.
- Regular income tax: $886,000. We checked the alternative minimum tax; it does not apply on these facts.
- NIIT: 3.8% × the lesser of $4,000,000 or ($4,000,000 − $200,000) = $144,400 (§1411).
Three outcomes, depending on the creditability question:
| A. Lump sum not creditable | B. Creditable, normal source rules | C. Fully creditable (theoretical ceiling) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| U.S. income tax before credit | $886,000 | $886,000 | $886,000 |
| Foreign tax credit | $0 | −$87,000 | −$348,000 |
| NIIT (no credit allowed) | $144,400 | $144,400 | $144,400 |
| U.S. tax due | $1,030,400 | $943,400 | $682,400 |
| Italian lump sum | $348,000 | $348,000 | $348,000 |
| Total tax | $1,378,400 | $1,291,400 | $1,030,400 |
| Effective rate | 34.5% | 32.3% | 25.8% |
How we got there:
- Scenario A assumes the IRS treats the lump sum as non-creditable. Claire pays full U.S. tax plus the Italian charge.
- Scenario B assumes the lump sum is a creditable §903 tax. Treas. Reg. §1.861-20 assigns foreign taxes to income categories based on the items of income in the foreign tax base. It does not say how to apply that rule to a charge with no base, so we allocate the lump sum pro rata to the income it covers. That is our assumption, not an IRS rule. That puts 25% ($87,000) on the UK dividends. The remaining $261,000 is attributable to U.S.-source income and produces no credit. The U.S. tax cap on the UK-dividend slice is roughly $190,000 after the capital-gains rate adjustment, so the full $87,000 is usable. The Art. 23(4)(c) resourcing rule might increase the credit, but its application to a lump sum is untested.
- Scenario C shows the most Claire could ever get: every euro credited. Even then her total bill is $1,030,400, which is exactly what she would have owed in federal tax alone without ever moving, for example while living in a U.S. state with no income tax.
The same person in Greece or the UK:
- Greece: the €100,000 lump sum ($116,000) brings Scenario A to $1,146,400 (28.7%). In the best case she again pays $1,030,400.
- UK, during the FIG window: the UK charges nothing on this foreign income. With nothing to credit, the U.S. bill is $1,030,400, and that is her total.
In every case the U.S. tax is the floor. These regimes can only reduce the local tax down to that floor. They do this most cleanly where the local tax is zero (UK) or where a lump sum is fully creditable (unproven). They never reduce the U.S. tax itself.
Common mistakes
Relying on a local adviser who doesn't know U.S. rules
Italian, Greek, and British advisers are usually right about their own country's law. The "near-zero" figure is accurate for the local return. What's missing is the second return, the one you file with the IRS every year as a citizen. Ask any adviser who pitches one of these regimes to show you the combined U.S. and local numbers for your actual income mix.
Assuming every foreign tax is creditable dollar for dollar
A foreign payment is creditable only if it is an income tax, or an in-lieu tax, as the U.S. regulations define those terms (Publication 514). A fixed lump sum is the hardest case under those rules. Even when a tax is creditable, it offsets only U.S. tax on foreign-source income, and much of a typical American portfolio is U.S.-source.
Forgetting the time limits and the ways to lose the regime
- The UK window is only four tax years, and unclaimed years still count (HS266).
- In Italy, a missed or partial payment ends the regime, and you can never elect it again (art. 24-bis(4)).
- In Greece, failing to complete the €500,000 investment cancels the regime back to the first year (AADE). The result is ordinary worldwide Greek taxation for years you thought were settled.
Assuming last year's price still applies
Italy's lump sum has tripled since 2017, from €100,000 to €300,000 (art. 24-bis notes). The amount you pay depends on when you moved, so check it against the version of the law in force on your arrival date.
FAQ
Can I use the foreign earned income exclusion instead?
Only for earned income. Section 911 excludes foreign earned income, which means pay for personal services. It does not cover dividends, interest, or capital gains, which are what these regimes are built around.
Does the UK FIG regime help an American at all?
Yes, on the UK side. Without the FIG regime, the UK would tax your foreign income on the arising basis, sometimes at rates above U.S. rates, and any UK tax above the U.S. tax would be an extra cost. With FIG, your UK tax on that income is zero and your total bill falls to the U.S. tax alone. What it can't do is take you below the U.S. tax. You also lose your UK personal allowance for any year you claim (HS266).
Should I exclude the United States from Italy's flat tax under art. 24-bis(5)?
Possibly, but this needs to be modeled. If you exclude the U.S., your U.S.-source income goes back under ordinary Italian taxation, with an Italian foreign tax credit (art. 24-bis(5)). The treaty's rules for U.S. citizens in Italy then decide how much each country credits (Art. 23(4)). Excluding the U.S. trades a creditability question for a known calculation, but it can raise your Italian tax. It also has an estate-planning cost: according to the Agenzia's guidance as reported by the Italian financial press, the Italian inheritance and gift tax exemption does not cover assets located in a country you have excluded (Il Sole 24 Ore). Run both versions with your actual numbers.
Is Greece's €100,000 regime a better deal for Americans than Italy's?
The local cost is lower, and when the lump sum turns out not to be creditable, that local cost is what you lose. But the U.S. tax is identical in both countries, and it is usually the larger number. Greece also requires a €500,000 investment, and an incomplete investment cancels the regime retroactively (AADE).
I hold a green card, not a passport. Is my position different?
The default rule is the same: resident aliens are taxed on worldwide income (Reg. §1.1-1(b)). Unlike a citizen, a green card holder may sometimes be treated as a resident of the other country under a treaty tie-breaker. For long-term residents, though, claiming treaty residence elsewhere can count as giving up U.S. residence under §7701(b)(6), with possible expatriation-tax consequences. Get specialist advice before taking that position.
Sources
Primary sources
United States
- 26 U.S.C. §1, §61, §865, §903, §904, §911, §1401, §1411, §2031, §6038D, §7701
- Treas. Reg. §1.1-1; Treas. Reg. §1.861-20; 31 C.F.R. §1010.350 (FBAR)
- Treas. Reg. §1.901-2 (eCFR)
- Treas. Reg. §1.903-1 (eCFR); text as reproduced by Tax Notes
- IRS Notice 2023-55
- Rev. Proc. 2025-32; IRS release on 2026 inflation adjustments
- IRS Publication 514 (2025)
- Cook v. Tait, 265 U.S. 47 (1924)
- SSA totalization agreement summaries: Italy, Greece, United Kingdom
Treaties
- U.S.–Italy: Treasury Technical Explanation of the 1999 Convention; IRS competent authority arrangement citing Art. 1(2)
- U.S.–Greece Convention (1950) and Protocol (1953), IRS
- U.S.–UK Convention (2001) as amended by the 2002 Protocol, consolidated text, GOV.UK; S.I. 2002/2848, legislation.gov.uk
Italy
- Art. 24-bis TUIR (D.P.R. 917/1986), consolidated text as updated May 23, 2026, Brocardi.it
- Law No. 199 of December 30, 2025 (2026 Budget Law), art. 1, paragraphs 25–26, Official Gazette extract; Gazzetta Ufficiale, Serie Generale no. 301 of December 30, 2025
- Agenzia delle Entrate, Provvedimento of March 8, 2017 and instructions for the new-resident option check-list
- Agenzia delle Entrate, Circular 17/E of May 23, 2017
Greece
- AADE, "Tax incentives for new tax residents, articles 5A, 5B, 5C" (November 12, 2025); earlier AADE edition (September 2023)
- AADE press release, July 20, 2026
- Art. 5A, Law 4172/2013 (text via Taxheaven)
United Kingdom
- HMRC, HS266 Foreign income and gains (FIG) regime (2026), updated May 18, 2026
- HM Treasury, Reforming the taxation of non-UK individuals (October 2024)
- HMRC Manual RDRM76100
Secondary sources
- DWF, "2026 Budget Law: key tax changes" (January 2026): effective date of Italy's €300,000 amount
- EC News, interpello for new residents: mismatch between the statute and the 2017 Provvedimento
- eDotto, Notariato study on new residents: quotes Law 232/2016, art. 1(158); Il Sole 24 Ore: inheritance-tax exemption and excluded countries
- KPMG, Notice 2023-80 extends FTC relief (December 11, 2023); Weil and RSM (2023) on Notice 2023-55
- Current Federal Tax Developments (August 31, 2026): Federal Circuit's chapter 1 reasoning
- KPMG TaxNewsFlash 2026-202 (August 31, 2026) and RSM (November 5, 2026): Federal Circuit decisions in Christensen and Bruyea
- US-UK Tax, "US Tax Return Preparation for Expats Taking Italy's Flat Tax" (October 28, 2026)
- Tax Foundation, 2026 Tax Brackets; Kiplinger, 2026 capital gains thresholds
- Pound Sterling Live, EUR/USD history 2026: exchange rate used in the example
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. The rules discussed here, especially the Italian, Greek, and UK regimes and the U.S. foreign tax credit regulations, change frequently, and the creditability of lump-sum taxes is unsettled. The worked example is a simplified illustration that ignores many factors (including deductions, other income, family members, timing of payment, and currency rules). Consult a qualified advisor who practices in both U.S. and local tax law before you make a residence decision or take a filing position.
